PDA

View Full Version : Illinois - Job is hell after return from leave, possible case? Illinois


toadstool78
11-19-2006, 12:18 PM
I am writing on behalf of my wife who has been undergoing a struggle at work after returning from maternity leave.

Back in March '06 my wife went on maternity leave after the birth of our daughter, and was on a leave of absence/maternity leave for 12 weeks. While she was gone they hired a contracted temp to fill her position for 3 months. While my wife was on leave she received her annual review of her job which she was rated as excellent [4.5 out of 5]. Upon her return things were pretty much how they had been, and my wife was back in her regular role. About 4 weeks after her return her immediate boss [boss #1] gave two weeks notice. The week after she left my wife now reported to the VP of the department [boss #2], and was pulled into a meeting with her and told that she was not doing her job well [and that the only thing that had changed in the office was that my wife was back], and as a result of that some responsibilities were being taken from her and given to the temp [who was now filling the position of boss #1]. My wife worked under this scenario for about 3 weeks. Then my wife set up a meeting with boss #2 to discuss her progress, and was told that she needed to improve several things, that were documented in an email following the meeting. My wife improved all of those items, and has since attempted to hold meetings twice to discuss her progress, none which were accepted. My wife then went to HR to ask for some assistance in what to do, she was told that she should set up the meeting with boss #2s secretary, and that my wife may need to go on a "performance improvement plan" [which is effectively probation, and cannot change jobs within the company for 1 year, and can have her bonus withheld at the call of boss #2]. She set up the meeting [titled "Susie's Progress"] and met with boss #2 this past Friday, which lasted 5 minutes with boss #2 saying "I wasn't prepared to talk about your progress, and we will be meeting with HR early next week"].

Misc. background knowledge.
My wife met with HR on several occasions [after which the information was shared with the VP]
The VP on several occasions made comments to my wife like "Those clothes are looking a little small" while she was pregnant.

My question [if you're still with me] is, should my wife be terminated do you think that we have a plausible case for discrimination since all of this changed after her return from maternity leave? Also what options does she have if presented with a "performance improvement plan" other than signing it, is there something that she can do to show the documentation that direction she has been getting has been conflicting?

Thanks

ElleMD
11-20-2006, 01:57 PM
I'm not seeing how any of this is related to taking maternity leave 6 months ago. Her boss at the time thought her performance was great. That person left and the new sheriff in town so to speak does not agree. Unless she has some reason other than "it could be" to believe that the reason this person is disatisfied with her is that she took maternity leave back in March, I don't see any recourse.

toadstool78
11-20-2006, 09:29 PM
ElleD

Thanks for the reply. I think that perhaps I wasn't clear enough in my post with the background information.

Yes it is true that my wife has a new boss, in some respects this was the boss of her boss, which meant that the excellent [formal] performance review that she received was signed by this same woman. And the fact that this has been an ongoing issue with this woman since my wife was pregnant seems to have carried over, and has been continually treated this way since she returned from maternity leave.

Needless to say my wife is looking for a new job, but it would be nice to have some assistance to help her. And unfortunately her HR representative is proving to not be of much assistance, and all of her suggestions benefit the VP, and at the same time hurt my wife.

Pretty much it all boils down to the fact that my wife and this woman have never gotten along, and although they are both at fault to some extent there is zero accountability for her boss.

I'm sure that I'm forgetting more, just a little emotional about it, and it all makes sense when I write it, but I also have all the background knowledge.

Thanks again

cbg
11-20-2006, 09:31 PM
If they have never gotten along, that's still not related to her maternity leave of six months ago.

Complete Labor Law Poster for $24.95
from www.LaborLawCenter.com, includes
State, Federal, & OSHA posting requirements