in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian at
patrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am:
I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin. Julia

Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? Di


No Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which you
and Jackie are the masters.

Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his own
legs off.

Robin

>Subject: Re: Legally Enforceable Open Adoption?From: Robin phthalyoginous@harritt.netDate: 5/24/04 1:04 AM Pacific Daylight TimeMessage-id: <BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian atpatrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am: I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin. Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? DiNo Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which youand Jackie are the masters.Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his ownlegs off.Robin

I bet she helped and owns the chain saw. ;-)


Kathy

>Subject: Re: Legally Enforceable Open Adoption?From: Robin phthalyoginous@harritt.netDate: 5/24/04 1:04 AM Pacific Daylight TimeMessage-id: <BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian atpatrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am: I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin. Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? DiNo Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which youand Jackie are the masters.Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his ownlegs off.Robin

I bet she helped and owns the chain saw. ;-)


Kathy

Robin <phthalyoginous@harritt.net> wrote in message news:<BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>... in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian at patrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am: I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin. Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? Di No Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which you and Jackie are the masters. Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his own legs off. Robin

Are you trying to tell us that Cindy deliberately set out to develop
her depressive illness now?

Robin <phthalyoginous@harritt.net> wrote in message news:<BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>... in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian at patrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am: I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin. Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? Di No Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which you and Jackie are the masters. Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his own legs off. Robin

Are you trying to tell us that Cindy deliberately set out to develop
her depressive illness now?

>Subject: Re: Legally Enforceable Open Adoption?From: patrice068@optusnet.com.au (Dian)Date: 5/24/04 7:24 PM Pacific Daylight TimeMessage-id: <9a095db9.0405241824.55dea10c@posting.google.com>Robin <phthalyoginous@harritt.net> wrote in messagenews:<BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>... in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian at patrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am:> I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy> dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin.>> Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? Di No Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which you and Jackie are the masters. Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his own legs off. RobinAre you trying to tell us that Cindy deliberately set out to developher depressive illness now?

Nobody blamed her for her depressive illness. You are projecting again.
Kathy

>Subject: Re: Legally Enforceable Open Adoption?From: patrice068@optusnet.com.au (Dian)Date: 5/24/04 7:24 PM Pacific Daylight TimeMessage-id: <9a095db9.0405241824.55dea10c@posting.google.com>Robin <phthalyoginous@harritt.net> wrote in messagenews:<BCD76B0A.41AFB%phthalyoginous@harritt.net>... in article 9a095db9.0405232349.109575ee@posting.google.com, Dian at patrice068@optusnet.com.au wrote on 24/5/04 8:49 am:> I had sympathy for her while she lived with depression. My sympathy> dried up when I saw her crumpled children with her coffin.>> Julia Isn't blaming her for the consequences of her mental illness the same as blaming a man without legs for not walking? Di No Di, that's what's called a non sequitur. A logical pratfall of which you and Jackie are the masters. Unless of course you know a man somewhere who has deliberately cut his own legs off. RobinAre you trying to tell us that Cindy deliberately set out to developher depressive illness now?

Nobody blamed her for her depressive illness. You are projecting again.
Kathy